Breaking News
Local News

Here’s another chance to understand TIF

By by ROBERT E. OLIVER 4 min read

More than one reader has asked us to further explain Tax Increment Financing [TIF]. Last Monday night, action by the City Council of Webster City approved 2028 TIF payments to six Webster City companies. This presents another opportunity to understand TIF more fully.

TIF is almost the only economic development tool left to the discretion of county and local government in Iowa. Except for TIF, the rest of Webster City's aggressive economic development work relies on the Ames Regional Economic Alliance, working with, and through, the Iowa Economic Development Authority [IEDA]. Since May 2024, when both Hamilton County and Webster City joined the Ames Alliance, we've seen a steady stream of IEDA support for downtown revitalization, housing development, and Gateway Industrial Park.

Finally, there's the often behind-the-scenes work of the Hamilton County Growth Partnership. With a membership spanning both private and public sectors, it has, in a very short time, created a powerful consensus among local leaders. From an economic development perspective, it's our pipeline to the Ames Alliance and IEDA.

TIF came to Iowa in 1957, when the Legislature enacted the state's first urban renewal act. Its use was mostly confined to larger cities, until it was realized smaller cities and towns were missing opportunities for local economic growth afforded by TIF.

Webster City's first TIF district, the Riverside Urban Renewal District, was created in 1986. It helped pay for local impacts of the nearly $100 million WCI Laundry Division expansion, conversion of the former Riverview Elementary School to Riverview Day Care, and a facelift downtown.

But what did City Council actually approve last Monday? It ratified staff-recommended annual TIF rebates for six local companies as shown below:

1 Fareway – $15,500. TIF rebates began in 2014, for a term of 14 years.

2 3DK Enterprises – $13,500. TIF rebates began in 2015 for a term of 13 years.

3 Gary & Brenda Fox, (Appliance Plus) – $30,000. TIF rebates began in 2021 for a term of 9 years.

4 First State Bank – $40,000. TIF rebates began in 2021 for a term of 10 years.

5 People's Credit Union – $4,500. TIF rebates began in 2024 for a term of 10 years.

6 Lynx Development – $110,000. TIF rebates began in 2021 for a term of 16 years.

When each of these firms decided to expand in Webster City, they negotiated a temporary reduction in property taxes for a set number of years. The terms of these TIF contracts are complex and vary depending on the size and value of the improvement.

These expansions have brought us a larger grocery store, new storage units, a new appliance/furniture retailer in an empty storefront (the former Shopco store), improved bank and credit union facilities and services, and a subdivision of 61 new single-family homes.

Many of these improvements resulted in new jobs, a better selection of goods and services, and an improved quality of life in Webster City. Some of the projects wouldn't have been built without a TIF incentive. In exchange for investing here, TIF allows these companies to share in the value they add to the city, by paying reduced property taxes for a negotiated term of years. At the end of the term, the rebates cease, and companies must pay taxes on the higher assessed value of their property.

It's important to understand the rebates are not subsidized by other taxpayers. The "I" in TIF stands for increment. This is defined as the value of the property after the improvement is made, vs. its value before. That incremental value of the property is what ultimately puts more tax money into the city's coffers.

We won't pretend that's all there is to TIF. It's governed by a complicated set of laws, but we hope it helps de-mystify an economic development tool that plays a key role in our economic future, and one we'll be talking about for a long time to come.

Starting at /week.